Select Pet Awards 2023: The best food and accessories for dogs and cats
Guided and recommended by veterinarians, we tried and chose our favorite pet food products across kibble, treats, bowls and more.
Award: Best Wet Food | Pet Type: Dog
Similarly, the veterinarians we spoke to recommend Purina Pro Plan — which makes some of our favorite wet dog food — as an award winner and one of the best brands to consider for dog food, specifically because it employs veterinary nutritionists, uses feeding trials and performs regular quality testing. Purina Pro Plan offers food for dogs in a variety of life stages, including puppies and senior dogs (ages 7 years and up), breed sizes and certain health considerations, including weight management and sensitive skin and stomach.
“My dog is a picky eater and Purina does a great job of providing a variety of options,” says commerce analytics manager Amanda Smith, who feeds her 2-year-old, 27-pound rat terrier, Mac, the brand’s dry food and prepared meal stew. “I also love that they're really intentional about the products they put out — you can find the food that's best for your specific dog to help them in whatever stage of life they're in.”
Award: Best Treats | Pet Type: Dog
These chicken-flavored, low-calorie treats for dogs receive a stamp of approval from our veterinarians and the Best for Your Pet award for treats because they’re high quality, tasty and avoid adding extra calories to your pet’s diet. The experts we spoke to note that treats often contain a large amount of fat and salt because it makes them more palatable for dogs, which can add unnecessary calories and affect their health over time. Opting for low-calorie treats like these can keep your pet within the AAFCO-recommended daily nutrition intake, according to our experts. Hill's Natural Baked Light Biscuits contain vitamins, minerals and phytonutrients and are free of corn and artificial colors and flavors, according to the brand. The brand offers these treats in small and medium biscuit sizes.
Award: Best Dry Food | Pet Type: Cat
Our veterinarians recommend Purina’s ONE Indoor Advantage as an award winner for the best dry cat food because it promotes healthy weight control — in fact, one veterinarian we spoke to feeds this formula to her own cat regularly. This formula contains natural fiber to help reduce your cat's hairballs, as well as antioxidants to support their immune system, according to the brand. The food is available in turkey, salmon and chicken flavors, and you can choose between four bag sizes ranging from 3.5 pounds to 22 pounds.
Award: Best Wet Food | Pet Type: Cat
Another brand chosen by our veterinarians also works with a team of veterinary nutritionists to ensure its food meets AAFCO standards, Hill’s Science Diet considers your pets’ weight, skin, stomach and more when formulating its food. The brand offers a range of wet cat food for a variety of feline sizes and ages, including kittens and senior cats (ages 7 years and up), as well as prescription options for dietary and health needs like sensitive skin and stomach, kidney care, weight management and urinary care. You’ll also find a variety of flavors, including poached salmon and spinach, roasted chicken and rice, and savory turkey.
Rebecca Rodriguez, NBC Select’s editorial projects associate, feeds both of her cats Hill’s Science Diet wet cat food and says they eat it quickly and consistently. "It also isn’t super smelly like other wet cat foods I’ve tried and the consistency is palatable for my cats," she says.
Award: Best Treats | Pet Type: Cat
NBC Select’s associate updates editor Zoe Malin feeds her three cats — Wanda, Gus and Zeke — these Temptations cat treats and considers them the perfect size and consistency to put in a treat dispenser like the Furbo and treat puzzles. “Since they’re crunchy on the outside yet soft on the inside, cats of all ages can easily chew them — Wanda could eat them when she had tiny baby teeth and Zeke, now that he’s 13 years old, can eat them even though his teeth have gotten weaker as he’s aged,” Malin says.
The veterinarians we spoke to also recommend Temptations — both the crunchy treats and the soft food pouches — because they’re highly palatable for cats. The treats are chicken-flavored and include a crunchy outside and a soft and creamy inside. They’re also packed with vitamins and taurine, which is an amino acid that helps support your cat’s overall health, according to the brand. You can purchase these in a variety of flavors, including salmon and shrimp, and in multiple packaging sizes ranging from 1.7-ounce to 48-ounce bags.
Award: Best Food Bowl | Pet Type: Cat
This set of two ceramic cat bowls sits snugly in a bamboo holder that’s elevated nearly 5 inches off the ground and slightly tilted 15 degrees to help reduce strain and pressure on your pet’s neck and avoid messes from the bowls slipping around the floor, according to the brand. Malin finds the stand to be very sturdy and says it doesn’t move around when her cats eat from it (though she did note that the height might be a little too tall for young kittens). She also likes that the cat bowls are easy to clean. “You can wipe off the bamboo stand with a gentle cleaning solution or damp cloth, and the ceramic bowls are smooth, making them easy to hand-wash,” Malin says.
Award: Best Food Bowl | Pet Type: Dog
This stainless steel pet bowl from Owala has a nonslip, circular base and comes in two capacities: 3 cups and 6 cups. Godio considers the 3-cup size perfect for the amount of food Bella eats daily. She loves that the bowl has a minimalist, sleek design and that it’s taller than other options she’s tried in the past (nearly 3-inches-tall for the 3-cup size and 3.5-inches-tall for the 6-cup size), which prevents Bella — who is normally a messy eater — from spilling kibble while she eats.
“My favorite part about Owala’s Dog Bowl is the thick, silicone ring on the bottom that prevents it from slipping or moving while pets eat and drink from it — we put ours on tile and wood floors and it doesn’t move at all,” says Malin, who uses it primarily as a water bowl for her 10-year-old, 120-pound lab, Chance.
Award: Best Food Bowl | Type: Automatic
The Wopet Automatic Pet Feeder has a 7-liter tank capacity and a programmable timer that lets you schedule up to five meals per day with 10 grams per portion. “This automatic feeder has changed the game for us. We don’t have to worry about running home to feed the cats while we’re out,” Rodriguez says. “We set ours to go off four times a day — the only downside is that if you feed your cat wet food, you’ll have to do that separately.”
The feeder lets you record a customizable message to encourage your pet to approach it during their meal times, which Rodriguez says is her favorite feature. The lid locks into place, so you don’t run the risk of your pet breaking into the food bank. It also includes infrared detection to prevent food from spilling or getting stuck in the food outlet, according to the brand. Wopet recommends filling the tank with dry kibble between 2 and 15 millimeters in size.
Award: Best Treat Dispenser
Several NBC Select staffers call this Wild One Treat Bag “life-changing” and note it’s the perfect accessory for walks. “You can hold so much in the pouch-like your phone, keys and treats, and there are little dividers so you can keep treats away from your other items,” Malin says. “If you have this, you can keep your hands free and just hold your pet leash or carrier, or an umbrella if it’s rainy and you have to take your dog out.”
Godio loves the pouch’s magnetic opening, which she says makes it easy to quickly reach in and grab treats without needing to battle a zipper. “I used this treat pouch to train recall with Bella at the park and having easy access to treats while still being able to use my hands for commands makes the process so much easier,” she says.
When a product carries the Select badge, you can trust that our team of editors as shopping experts and professionals vetted the item thoroughly. We are journalists, first and foremost, which means we will always do our research and reporting.
To ensure our product picks are more than just editor-approved, we used a panel of experts, including veterinarians, pet groomers and veterinary technicians to give buying advice for each category. When conferring with our experts, we asked them for advice they would give to their patients or clients. Some members of our expert panel recommended individual products. Other products we gave awards to are ones we use in our own lives.
Catch up on Select's in-depth coverage of personal finance, tech and tools, wellness and more, and follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter to stay up to date.
