As with every skin care and makeup product, there are several things to consider in a primer when you struggle with acne and breakouts:
Eight NBC Select editors, many of whom have sensitive, acne-prone skin, put their skin on the line to test more than 30 primers over two months. Here’s what we kept in mind while testing:
Want more from NBC Select? Sign up for our newsletter, The Selection, and shop smarter.
Since we started testing makeup, our NBC Select editors have consistently loved Lancome’s products — they’re reliable, long-wearing and safe for sensitive, acne-prone skin. This primer is no different; it’s the perfect balance of blurring and lightweight, so it doesn’t feel heavy or sticky despite creating one of the smoothest bases I’ve ever felt on my skin. It made my makeup last all day in 90-degree Florida weather with no issues. Plus, it goes on completely clear and doesn’t have a scent.
NBC Select editorial operations associate Jem Alabi agrees: “Lancome is my favorite primer by far — it has the perfect consistency and my makeup didn’t move all day when I used it,” she says. “It has a gel-like, watery texture, so it doesn’t feel sticky at all, which is a huge deal for me because I hate sticky primers. I felt my foundation glide on my skin after using it. It’s pricey, but it’s the best I’ve ever tried.”
I love the feel of this primer — it’s extremely lightweight, non-sticky and absorbs very quickly. It has a similar feel to a water-gel moisturizer, so it goes on smoothly and my skin essentially drinks it up. In addition to giving me a healthy glow that I can see even with a full face of makeup on, it also leaves my dry skin feeling soft and hydrated. NBC Select reporter Zoe Malin likes that this primer helps her foundation go on more evenly, and she says she noticed a difference in how bright her face looked with makeup on. “I got a ton of compliments on my skin when I was wearing this. People said my skin looked especially glowy and dewy, which is a look I like, and the primer is supposed to be illuminating, so that’s a good sign,” says Malin.
“I’m a sucker for a gel primer, and this is one of my favorites,” says NBC Select associate SEO reporter Ashley Morris. The primer has a matte finish, helps minimize the appearance of pores and controls excess oil, which makes it a great option for those with oily skin. “When I initially applied it, I was worried the pink tint would look odd on my face, but it ended up blending perfectly. It helped subdue a lot of my excess oil and worked really well on its own over my usual sunscreen and moisturizer combo,” says Morris, who has oily, acne-prone skin. “I especially love using it with concealer, mascara and lip gloss — it’s the ideal base product for those hot days when you want a polished look with minimal makeup.”
My first impression of this primer was how lightweight it was; it has a serum consistency that makes it feel more like skin care than a typical makeup product. Since it has a more watery texture compared to other primers I’ve tried, I was skeptical about how well it would make my makeup last. To my surprise, it created a smooth, hydrated base for even the most full-coverage makeup looks. It leaves my skin feeling smoother than any other primer I tested, and it helps control oil and shine on hotter days, so I can comfortably wear it with or without makeup and reap the benefits. I also love the packaging (though it did take me a second to figure out) — I can press the bottom of the bottle to control exactly how much product comes out, and the pointed tip controls any mess.
This Versed primer not only provides a great base for makeup, but it’s also at a fantastic price point, says Alabi. “It’s mattifying, so it blurs pores and imperfections, plus the pump helps me control exactly how much product comes out, which I appreciate,” she says. It also has the consistency and feel of a typical lotion, so it adds a hydrating boost to your makeup routine.
However, it is thick, which means you have to put in a little more effort to rub it in, says Alabi. The primer is safe for sensitive skin, has hyaluronic acid to hydrate your skin, and has niacinamide to help brighten and even out your skin tone, according to the brand.
“This primer stick is quite literally a pore eraser. Even before I put foundation over it, I could tell how matte it made my skin and how practically invisible it made my pores,” says Malin, who adds that this is one of the best primers she’s ever tried. When she layered on her makeup, Malin says it looked smooth, even and almost airbrushed all day. “I was hesitant about a primer stick before trying Milk’s since I usually like creamy products, but now I’m obsessed. Anything in stick form is just so convenient, and this is no different,” says Malin. The primer also has a buttery soft consistency, so it glides right onto the skin without pulling.
Tatcha’s The Liquid Silk Canvas absolutely lives up to its name — it has a lightweight, silky texture that absorbs almost instantly into my skin, and it blurred my bumps, pores and other imperfections to create a super smooth canvas for makeup. Best of all, this primer made my makeup look almost exactly like when I first applied it after over eight hours of walking around in the sun and running errands. It was more effective at making my makeup last than 99% of primers I tested. One of my only downsides is its strong floral scent — I still smell it even after I apply my makeup, so if you’re sensitive to scents, you may want to try another option.
“Before trying this product, I had never used a two-in-one moisturizer and primer. And now, I don’t think I can go back to using anything else,” says NBC Select associate social media editor Caitlin Cusack. “This primer feels super lightweight and hydrating, which is a must for my acne-prone skin. It instantly gives a glowy look — I’ve even worn it alone without any makeup.” Cusack’s makeup stays put all day without looking cakey, even after hours in the hot sun.
When using this primer, Morris loves that she doesn’t need to layer multiple products in hot weather, which can usually make her skin feel heavy and weighed down. “It has a smoothing finish that blurs out texture while still looking really natural, and the formula is so lightweight that it feels like a very thin moisturizer rather than a primer,” says Morris.
When I first tested this primer, I was worried about its thick texture — however, it absorbed so quickly and easily into my skin, I didn’t feel any heaviness after I applied it. Plus, my skin felt smooth and soft afterward, which created a perfect canvas for my makeup routine. Keep in mind it does have a strong citrus scent, which can be overpowering when applying it, says Cusack.
If you’re looking for an easy way to add SPF to your makeup routine, this Ciele primer is the way to go. It has SPF 30 protection (the minimum amount recommended by dermatologists) and zinc oxide, a mineral sunscreen ingredient recommended by our experts for those with sensitive, acne-prone skin. When I initially tested this out, I was worried it would be too thick to blend out and would make my makeup look cakey since it’s a mineral sunscreen. But I was very pleasantly surprised: Not only did this primer seamlessly blend into my skin, but it also created a smooth base that sat perfectly underneath my makeup without causing any cakiness, dryness or pilling (and made both lighter skin tints and full coverage foundations last all day long). I love that I can use it on its own as a typical sunscreen or as a base for my makeup.
This cream feels more like a silky moisturizer than a traditional primer: It’s thick, creamy and leaves my dry skin feeling smooth, soft and hydrated immediately after I apply it. I use this one on my drier days when I want to prep my skin for heavier makeup and prevent foundation and concealer from sticking to my dry patches. The primer has peptides to keep skin firm, oat extract and glycerin to soothe, and hyaluronic acid to add a boost of hydration, according to the brand. I’m also a fan of the packaging: It’s sleek enough to keep out on my makeup counter, and the pump packaging makes it easy to control how much comes out. Plus, a little goes a very long way with this primer, so I only need about a pump to get the amount I need.
This NYX primer is another editor favorite that you can buy at your local drugstore. “It has a very sticky consistency that provides a really great base for my acne-prone skin,” says Cusack. “My makeup always goes on really nicely with this primer and stays for hours without separating or looking cakey. Plus, a little product goes a long way, so it’s definitely a great value.” The primer has hyaluronic acid to hydrate the skin and vitamin E to moisturize and soothe inflammation, so it’s great for those with active breakouts and redness.
NBC Select commerce editor Cory Fernandez was impressed by how smooth and lightweight this primer felt on his skin, including his delicate under-eye area. “It wasn’t greasy or shiny and it also didn’t irritate my eyes, which is common [with other primers],” he says. “I also didn’t have to use a lot of it to cover my whole face.” The applicator is small and pointed, making the primer easy to apply, specifically in more precise areas like the under eyes, says Fernandez.
I’ve used this primer for about a year, and it quickly turned into one of my all-time favorites. I especially love the roll-on applicator because it’s easy to apply and I don’t have to use my fingers to rub it in (though it does make it harder to control how much you’re putting on, in my experience). Since I have dry skin, I don’t typically like a sticky formula because it accentuates my dry patches, but this one manages to dry down smoothly while still providing enough grip for my makeup. I wore this primer under my favorite skin tint before a full workday and a thicker, full-coverage foundation before a night out, and it managed to keep my makeup intact for more than eight hours.
Not necessarily. Whether or not you need a primer depends on your specific skin type and what you’re looking for in terms of your makeup routine. Simply put, if you’re happy with how your makeup behaves on your skin without a primer, you don’t need to add it to your routine.
However, there are several benefits to using a primer depending on your skin: It can create a smoother canvas for makeup, help foundations, concealers and other makeup products better adhere to the skin, blur imperfections like pores and scars, and mattify oily skin. So, they’re best for those with oily skin, uneven texture, active breakouts and visible pores, according to my experts.
“Plus, for acne-prone skin, primers can offer a protective barrier between skin care and foundation, minimizing friction or irritation,” says Koestline.
The difference between silicone-based and water-based primers lies in both how they perform and how they interact with your skin and foundation, says celebrity and fashion makeup artist Gilbert Soliz. Here are the key differences:
Yes, you should match a water-based or silicone-based primer with its respective makeup. “Mismatched bases can compromise wear and texture,” says Koestline. For example, since silicone repels water, a water-based foundation over a silicone primer may slide or separate, says Gmyrek. Pairing a water-based primer with a water-based foundation (or silicone with silicone) can prevent your foundation from pilling and separating over time.
For acne-prone skin, avoid primers with heavy oils, including coconut oil, mineral oil or lanolin, which can clog pores and cause breakouts, says Gmyrek. Also, avoid primers with illuminating particles, which can highlight texture and make your acne look even more prominent.
At NBC Select, we work with experts who have specialized knowledge and authority based on relevant training and/or experience. We also take steps to ensure all expert advice and recommendations are made independently and without undisclosed financial conflicts of interest.
I’m an updates editor at NBC Select who has covered beauty and personal care for over five years. For this article, I spoke to board-certified dermatologists, makeup artists and cosmetic chemists about what to look for in primers for acne-prone skin. NBC Select editors also tested over 30 primers for two months to find the best ones to recommend.
Catch up on NBC Select’s in-depth coverage of tech and tools, wellness and more, and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and TikTok to stay up to date.
